PCB surface finish options

PCB Surface Finish: ENIG, ENEPIG, HASL, OSP, Silver & Tin

The surface finish protects exposed copper and sets solderability, pad flatness, shelf life, wire-bondability and RF loss. Here is how every major option compares and which one fits your board.

Most specified
ENIG
ENIG / HASL shelf life
12+ mo
For fine-pitch BGAs
Flat
Finish options
8

Reviewed by the AstroPCB engineering team · Updated · All PCB capabilities

PCB with ENIG pads and hard gold edge-connector fingers

Overview

What a PCB surface finish does.

A PCB surface finish is the coating on exposed copper pads that prevents oxidation and gives a solderable, sometimes bondable, surface. The choice trades off pad flatness, shelf life, solder-joint reliability, wire-bonding, high-frequency loss, lead-free compatibility and cost.

We offer all major finishes: HASL, lead-free HASL, ENIG, ENEPIG, OSP, immersion tin, immersion silver and electrolytic hard gold, with selective combinations such as ENIG plus hard-gold fingers on one board.

Comparison

Surface finish comparison.

Typical shelf lives under controlled storage; actual limits depend on packaging and humidity.
FinishFlatnessShelf lifeFine pitchRF above ~5 GHzRelative cost
ENIGExcellent12+ moYesFair (Ni loss)Medium
ENEPIGExcellent12+ moYesGoodHigher
HASL / LF-HASLPoor12+ moNo (<0.8 mm)FairLow
OSPExcellent3–6 moYesGoodLowest
Immersion silverExcellent6–12 moYesBestMedium
Immersion tinExcellent≈ 6 moYesGoodMedium
Hard goldGoodLongContacts—High

HASL vs ENIG

HASL vs ENIG: which PCB finish?

HASL (hot air solder leveling) dips the board in molten solder and levels it with hot air. It is robust and low cost, but the surface is uneven, so it is a poor fit for fine-pitch BGAs below about 0.8 mm and for via in pad. ENIG (electroless nickel immersion gold) plates a nickel barrier and a thin gold layer. It is flat, solders well on fine pitch and keeps for 12 months or more, at a higher cost. Choose HASL or lead-free HASL for through-hole and coarse-pitch boards where cost matters most; choose ENIG for BGAs, QFNs, via in pad and boards that will be stored before assembly.

Typical guidance; final choice depends on assembly and application.
HASL / lead-free HASLENIG
Surface flatnessUnevenFlat
Fine-pitch BGA / QFNNot recommended below ≈ 0.8 mmYes
Via in padNoYes
Shelf life12+ months12+ months
RF above ≈ 5 GHzFairFair (nickel loss)
Relative costLowMedium

ENIG

ENIG (electroless nickel immersion gold).

ENIG deposits 3–6 µm of electroless nickel and 0.05–0.1 µm of immersion gold. The nickel is the barrier against copper diffusion, and the gold protects the nickel and gives an excellent solderable surface. It is the most specified lead-free finish for complex assemblies: flat, coplanar pads for fine-pitch BGA and QFN, 12+ month shelf life and good joint reliability.

The known risk is black pad, a nickel-phosphorus corrosion defect that causes brittle joints. Mid-phosphorus chemistry (7–9% P) and good process control have largely eliminated it. If the risk must be removed entirely, specify ENEPIG.

ENEPIG

ENEPIG.

ENEPIG adds 0.05–0.15 µm of electroless palladium between nickel and gold. The palladium blocks the gold-nickel interaction behind black pad and gives better wire-bonding than ENIG. It is the standard finish where a board needs both soldering and gold or aluminum wire bonds, and it is common in automotive, aerospace and medical boards where joint integrity cannot be compromised.

HASL

HASL and lead-free HASL.

Hot air solder leveling dips the board in molten solder and levels it with hot-air knives. Traditional HASL uses tin-lead; lead-free HASL uses a SAC or tin-copper alloy. It offers excellent solderability, long shelf life and low cost, but pads are uneven, thicker at the edges and thinner in the middle. That makes it unsuitable for BGAs below about 0.8 mm pitch and for QFN thermal pads. For through-hole and coarse-pitch SMT boards, lead-free HASL is still a cost-effective choice, and the thermal shock of the process should be considered on thick or HDI boards.

OSP

OSP (organic solderability preservative).

OSP applies a thin organic layer to bare copper. It is very flat, low cost and fully lead-free. The trade-offs are a short shelf life (about 3–6 months), limited tolerance for multiple reflows because the film degrades with each thermal exposure, and a bare-copper look that makes AOI and visual inspection harder. It suits high-volume consumer electronics assembled soon after fabrication.

Immersion tin

Immersion tin.

Immersion tin deposits a thin tin layer directly on copper, giving flat, solderable pads at moderate cost and working well with press-fit connectors. Shelf life is moderate, around 6 months. Tin-whisker growth over time is the concern, so it is acceptable for most commercial electronics but avoided in aerospace, military and other high-reliability hardware.

Immersion silver

Immersion silver.

Immersion silver gives one of the flattest pad surfaces of any common finish and excellent solderability. Silver has the highest electrical conductivity of any metal and adds no magnetic nickel layer, so it gives the lowest surface loss at microwave frequencies. It is widely specified for RF and high-speed boards. Shelf life is about 6–12 months, and it tarnishes on sulfur exposure, so packaging and handling matter. See high frequency PCB.

Hard gold

Hard gold for contacts.

Electrolytic hard gold, gold with a small amount of cobalt or nickel over a nickel underlayer, is used for edge connectors, keypad contacts and other surfaces that see repeated insertion or wear. It is usually applied selectively, for example ENIG on pads with hard-gold fingers on the connector edge, with beveling as required.

Choosing

Which finish should you use?

  • Fine-pitch BGA / QFN, standard reliability: ENIG
  • Automotive, medical, aerospace or wire bonding: ENEPIG
  • Simple, coarse-pitch, low cost: lead-free HASL
  • RF above ~5 GHz: immersion silver (or ENEPIG)
  • High volume, short inventory cycle: OSP
  • Edge connectors: selective hard gold
  • Flex circuits: ENIG — see flex PCB
  • High reliability: avoid pure tin

FAQ

Common questions.

What is the best PCB surface finish?

There is no single best. ENIG is the usual default for fine-pitch assemblies; HASL is cheapest; ENEPIG suits wire bonding and high reliability; immersion silver suits RF.

ENIG vs HASL?

ENIG is flat and suits fine-pitch parts with long shelf life; HASL is cheaper but uneven and unsuitable below about 0.8 mm pitch.

How long does each finish last in storage?

Roughly ENIG and HASL 12+ months, immersion silver 6–12 months, immersion tin about 6 months and OSP 3–6 months under controlled storage.

Does surface finish affect RF performance?

Yes. ENIG’s nickel adds loss above about 5 GHz; immersion silver or ENEPIG are often preferred for RF.

What is black pad?

A nickel corrosion defect in ENIG that causes brittle joints; controlled chemistry minimizes it and ENEPIG avoids it.

Can I combine finishes on one board?

Yes, for example ENIG on pads and selective hard gold on edge-connector fingers.

HASL vs ENIG: which is better?

ENIG for fine-pitch, BGA, via in pad and long storage; HASL or lead-free HASL for low-cost through-hole and coarse-pitch boards.

Ready when your files are

Send your design for a capability check.

Upload Gerber, ODB++ or IPC-2581 data. Every quote includes a written engineering DFM review, typically within one business day.